Not in front of the servants: the case of the Acerbic Arushan

arson

Fiery background imagery from AcerbicArushan2. The photo is of farm invasions in Zimbabwe.

The “Acerbic Arushan” blog has been shut down. I came across this story in the Daily News, and thought we had another example of the Tanzanian government cracking down on inconvenient media. After all, MwanaHalisi newspaper has been closed down, editors at Mwananchi and Tanzania Daima have been taken to court, and journalist Daud Mwangosi was killed, to name just a few cases among many. I thought perhaps the battle against media freedom had moved back online. It wouldn’t be the first time.

But with just a little online investigating I found evidence that suggests this is a quite different matter. I wasn’t familiar with the Acerbic Arushan blog, or the controversy it has stirred among the expat community of Arusha and the surrounding area. 

At the time of writing (though perhaps not for long), a new blog, AcerbicArushan2 is up and running. This gives a sense of what the previous blog – now available only via Google’s web cache and similar services – was like:

“Inspiring, isn’t it? How just one tiny voice can threaten the high and mighty untouchable white elite here so seriously that they have to run screaming to anyone who will listen and cry for help like little babies.”

“Maybe when they are getting their eyeballs stabbed out with screwdrivers by an angry mob then they will at last understand what this blog was trying to tell them and their eyes will be opened (not literally of course cos they won’t actually have any eyes left by then).That would be a most fitting punishment because they are already blinded to the reality of what is going on all around them by their own greed.”

Racist Dolly resident Vicky wrote a book all about how great she is and how shit Tanzanians are. Classy lady.”

Ouch!

Unpleasant, angry and vicious? Yes. Libellous? Almost certainly. But a threat to the Tanzanian government? Hardly. No more than nuisance, upsetting the foreign (or settler) investors that the blog targets – people that the government would prefer to keep happy, but hardly top priority.

No, it seems much more likely that the blog has been closed down by Google – who run the blogger/blogspot platform – for breaching its content policy. There’s plenty in there that would allow Google to justify closing down the original Acerbic Arushan blog, presumably in response to complaints from the folks targeted by the blog’s vitriol.

This conclusion is effectively confirmed by recent statements in the comments section of AcerbicArushan2, by the blog’s author. She writes that “this blog was under review” and that it “has now passed.” That sounds much more like the kind of due process Google would to apply to cases like this than the Tanzania government.

The Acerbic Arushan herself says she is not Tanzanian. So it seems this is a battle waged between one member of Arusha’s expat community, unhappy about how other expats were behaving, and that community defending itself.

Not in front of the servants,” one might say. But only if you’re willing to risk marking yourself out as sharing the lifestyle and/or worldview of the community that has got the Acerbic Arushan so hot under the collar.

– – – – –

Update: The Acerbic Arushan has posted a response to this post on her blog.

4 thoughts on “Not in front of the servants: the case of the Acerbic Arushan

  1. Check your facts foundation

    I thought you were someone serious but you just believe everything you read.
    Do you know that the person you are praising has been encouraging racial hatred? do you know that the person you are praising has been promising money to destruct other’s property? Do you know that the person you are praising has been encouraging people to kill other people? Do you know that the person you are paising has been deforming facts so they stick to her own truth? Do you know that the person you are praising is writing the majority of the comments on her own blog?
    Please check your facts. I hope you are not like the blogger you are praising.

    1. mtega

      Can you please point out to me where exactly in the blog post I “praised” the Acerbic Arushan? I was not aware that I had done so, and that was certainly not my intention.

      Her blog raises a lot of questions about the appropriate boundaries of free speech, which I plan to look into in a later post. And it’s closure was of much interest to media observers in Tanzania, which was why I wrote this post. But I was very careful to write only about the blog’s closure and subsequent relaunch, not to pass judgement on either the blog’s style or its author’s views.

      I’m sorry if this has upset you in some way.

  2. Samuel Vimes

    “No more than nuisance” … hardly. Unfortunately the AA went from mild gossip-and-slander to actively inciting people to violence and murder, including offering large bribes to anyone who would show proof of having burned white-owned houses down. Having your own bone to pick with the often stuck-up, spoiled expat community is just fine. Many people I know welcomed the idea of some frank writing about the very real issues about inequality in Tanzania – but the thing we absolutely do NOT need is someone fanning the flames of racialism. We’re going through some tough times in Tanzania, with a mix of tragedy and great opportunity for change – we need to keep the ideas Mwalimu championed alive, and the AA is certainly no champion.

  3. anonymous

    No treat to the government? Taken down by google. I think you might have skipped a few posts. I think kikwete herself considers her a terrorist.

Comments are closed.