Has Zitto revealed fake news on Tz economic growth?

The Citizen, 2/11/2017

Zitto Kabwe was arrested last week. He must be getting used to this by now, as he’s been held and questioned by the police on several occasions over the past couple of years.

What’s new this time, however, is that along with the by-now commonplace charge of “sedition”, he has been charged under the Statistics Act – the first such charges brought since the Act became law in 2015. Specifically, he and his party, ACT Wazalendo, published their own analysis of official economic data from the Bank of Tanzania (BoT), suggesting that the official GDP growth figures had been manipulated, and that actual growth was 0.1% rather than the BoT figure of 5.7%. And somebody decided that these are sufficient grounds to have him arrested.

I am not an economist and cannot either confirm or reject Zitto’s claim. I hope others will try to do so. But I can put forward some related data on the state of Tanzania’s economy that might help shed some light on the situation.

Let’s start with Zitto’s figures, however. His argument is essentially that up to now, GDP growth in Tanzania has stuck fairly close to the rate calculated using inflation and money supply figures. The most recent data, however, show a marked diversion, led by a sharp drop in money supply. In other words, the two blue lines on this graph stayed fairly close until this year. So something must be wrong with the latest figures, in his view.

Whether or not this argument holds water, however, we can also examine other data that can tell us something about the state of the economy. I have four more charts for you, starting with the money supply (the amount of money held in Tanzania, either in cash or in bank accounts):

It’s up and down a bit, but it shows one thing pretty clear: that growth in money supply in Tanzania has dropped considerably since early 2016. Before that, the amount of money circulating in Tanzania had been growing at around 15% each year. But that has now dropped to around 5% this year.

Next up, let’s look at another important proxy for a nation’s economic health: imports and exports. If the economy is doing well, demand for imported goods and services and production of exports should be on the increase.

When it comes to exports, the figures are up and down, showing no clear trend. But imports of goods and services into Tanzania are down considerable since January 2015: down by roughly 35% in just over two years.

We can also look at credit to the private sector. Again, this can be a good measure of economic health: if the economy is strong, banks will be happy to lend money.

As with imports, so there has been a decline here: prior to 2016, lending to the private sector had grown at a rate of around 20% a year. This has now dropped to just 1% in the latest available figures, for July 2017.

Finally, an indicator that perhaps affects most Tanzanians lives more immediately than any of those presented above: food prices. This is a complex area, as higher prices can be good for producers just as they are bad for consumers. But price increases would suggest demand is outstripping supply. And if prices go very high, it would suggest there might be a serious food shortage.

It’s good to see that prices have come down considerably since the start of the year – when reports and evidence of food shortages were widespread, despite initial government denials. But it’s noticeable that prices are still well above where they were at this time in the season in 2015 and 2016.

I want to end with two questions:

First: Bank of Tanzania figures tell us that money supply growth is down, imports are down, credit to the private sector is sharply down, and food prices remain high. What does this tell us about the state of the Tanzanian economy?

And second: an opposition politician is arrested and charged for pointing to what he describes as significant anomalies in official data. What does this tell us about the state of Tanzanian democracy?


This post originally appeared on mtega.com.

4 thoughts on “Has Zitto revealed fake news on Tz economic growth?

  1. moses

    Dear Mtega, I thought after Zitto criticisms of the govt data, it would have been nice for the govt to come out well and respond intelligently with proof.I hate this tendency of arresting critics.It is a poison that is killing our thinking minds

    Reply
  2. Eliya Mlay

    I request Mr. Mtega to brief us of what I call “Currency terrorism” and how those in possession of the “fiat currency namely US dollar” can by any means conspire to devaluate another state’s currency. Because I am deeply convinced that is what the US has tried to do last week by Bloomberg for obscure reasons.

    Reply
  3. Godswill

    This is rudiculus if govt wont accept critics from other side. We need to build up our economy, everyday we found there is change in currency value to drop down vs usd while living cost raising. I advise govt to have transparency and loyal responsibility on other analyst Results.

    Reply
  4. Nick

    When I read this article in the news, I thought I need an opinion from the best guy in the world for interpreting economic statistics in Tanzania. Rushing to twitter, I found dismay by the “I am not an economist…”, after which you extrapolated all the data anyway. Left satisfied.

    Side note: I watched closely as the government of Zimbabwe lied about its statistics from about 2005. What doesn’t lie is the exchange rate to the dollar. The current rise in TZS:USD may be the annual “get more shillings for our exports” trick, but may also be a per-cursor to hyper-inflation.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *